There are music books you buy because you love the artist on the cover.
Then there are books that make you put them down, reach for your headphones and listen to something you thought you already knew.
Those are the ones I’m interested in.
For the first Our Picks selection at Beats Unbound, I didn’t want to make another list of famous musician biographies. There are plenty of those already. Instead, I went looking for books that take music somewhere else — into memory, culture, technology, psychology and the strange little worlds that grow around particular scenes.
Some are easier reads than others. A couple ask for a bit of patience. That’s fine. I don’t think a good music book has to be effortless.
It just has to leave you with something.
Affiliate disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you make a qualifying purchase through one of them, Beats Unbound may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. (paid link)
1. How Music Works — David Byrne
David Byrne’s How Music Works is probably the one I’d hand to someone who keeps asking why music sounds the way it does.
Not technically. Not only.
Byrne is interested in the things around the music: the room where it’s played, the technology used to record it, the audience, the musicians, the economics and even the architecture.
That’s what makes the book interesting.
A band playing in a tiny club isn’t quite the same band when it’s standing on a festival stage in front of 50,000 people. A recording studio changes what musicians can do. Even limitations can become part of a sound.
Byrne has spent enough of his life making music to have some very definite opinions about all this. You won’t necessarily agree with him on everything. I wouldn’t want you to.
The book is at its best when he’s making ordinary things suddenly seem worth thinking about. A Guardian review praised precisely that quality, describing the book as wide-ranging and full of plain-spoken observations about music and the world around it.
It made me think about something we don’t usually consider when listening to a record: how much of what we hear was shaped by circumstances that have nothing to do with the notes themselves.
Worth picking up if: you want to understand music as something made by people, in particular places, under particular circumstances.
Find *How Music Works* on Amazon
2. Meet Me in the Bathroom — Lizzy Goodman
Some music histories feel like history.
Meet Me in the Bathroom feels more like gossip from a very good night out.
That’s a compliment.
Lizzy Goodman’s oral history of New York’s indie-rock scene between 2001 and 2011 brings together musicians, journalists, managers and people who were simply close enough to what was happening to have a story.
The Strokes are here. So are Yeah Yeah Yeahs, LCD Soundsystem, Interpol and a whole network of people orbiting the same clubs and neighbourhoods.
The fun is in the contradictions.
Someone remembers a night one way. Someone else remembers it completely differently. A band that looked effortlessly cool from the outside was probably having a minor crisis backstage. Someone who seemed destined for greatness disappeared. Someone else unexpectedly became a star.
Goodman lets those voices sit next to each other rather than forcing everything into one neat version of events.
That can also be the book’s weakness. There are a lot of voices, and some readers find the sheer amount of interview material tiring. But I think that’s part of what makes it feel alive.
Music scenes aren’t tidy while they’re happening.
Worth picking up if: you like the people, places and accidents behind a music scene as much as the records themselves.
Find *Meet Me in the Bathroom* on Amazon
3. Please Kill Me — Legs McNeil & Gillian McCain
There’s nothing particularly respectable about Please Kill Me.
That’s part of its charm.
The book tells the story of the New York punk scene through interviews with the people who were actually there: Patti Smith, Iggy Pop, the New York Dolls, the Ramones, Television and plenty of other musicians and characters.
It gets ugly.
It’s funny.
Sometimes it’s ridiculous.
And every now and then you find yourself wondering how any of these people made it through the decade alive.
But underneath all of that is something I really like about the book: it refuses to turn punk into a museum exhibit.
Nobody knew they were creating a mythology while they were living it. They were just making noise, going to clubs, falling in love, falling out, getting into trouble and trying to make something that sounded different from everything around them.
The mythology came later.
That’s one reason oral history works so well for music. You get the memory before somebody has had the chance to tidy it up.
Worth picking up if: you want your music history messy, contradictory and very much alive.
Find *Please Kill Me* on Amazon
4. The Rest Is Noise — Alex Ross
This is the ambitious one.
Alex Ross takes on twentieth-century music and connects it to the world that produced it: wars, politics, technology, cities, modernism and changing ideas about what music was supposed to be.
It sounds intimidating.
At times, it is.
But there’s something rewarding about that ambition. Ross doesn’t treat music as though it developed separately from everything else happening around it.
And that opens up a more interesting question.
Not just:
What does this music mean?
But:
Why did somebody need to make music like this at that particular moment?
Those aren’t quite the same question.
You don’t need to be an expert in twentieth-century classical music to get something from the book. You just need some curiosity and, preferably, a willingness to let a book take its time.
This is probably not the one I’d recommend for a quick holiday read.
But it might be the one that changes the way you think about music and history.
Worth picking up if: you want to see music as part of a much larger cultural story.
Find *The Rest Is Noise* on Amazon
5. This Is Your Brain on Music — Daniel J. Levitin
You know that thing where three seconds of a song can suddenly put you somewhere you haven’t thought about in years?
You’re back in a car.
You’re twenty again.
It’s summer.
Someone is sitting beside you who hasn’t been in your life for a very long time.
And somehow the song remembers.
Daniel J. Levitin’s This Is Your Brain on Music is interested in why that happens.
Levitin looks at rhythm, melody, memory, expectation and the ways our brains process music. His background as both a musician and neuroscientist gives the book a useful perspective: he understands that music isn’t simply something we analyse. It’s something we experience.
The book is deliberately accessible, which is one reason it has reached such a broad audience. It isn’t trying to be a dense neuroscience textbook.
And it does have its limitations. Some readers find parts of it slow, while others have pointed out that its value is more in explaining cognitive psychology to a general audience than in presenting groundbreaking neuroscience.
But that doesn’t really bother me.
The question at the heart of the book is still fascinating:
Why can a song reach a memory that words can’t?
That’s enough to keep me reading.
Worth picking up if: you’re interested in the strange relationship between music, memory and emotion.
Find *This Is Your Brain on Music* on Amazon
So, Which One Should You Start With?
There’s no obvious winner here, and that’s probably a good thing.
If you want to understand how music gets made and why it sounds the way it does, go with David Byrne.
If you’re fascinated by music scenes and the people who create them, Meet Me in the Bathroom is hard to resist.
If punk is your world, start with Please Kill Me.
If you want the bigger picture — music, history and culture colliding with each other — Alex Ross is the one.
And if what interests you most is why music can get inside our memories so easily, pick up Levitin.
You don’t need all five.
That’s not what Our Picks is supposed to be.
The idea is simpler than that: we look around, find things we genuinely think are worth your time, and tell you why.
Sometimes that will be a pair of headphones.
Sometimes a record.
Sometimes a book that’s been sitting on someone’s shelf for fifteen years and still has something to say.
And if one of these books sends you back to an old song and makes you hear it differently, then it has done exactly what a good music book should do.
Our Picks
For understanding music: How Music Works
For music-scene stories: Meet Me in the Bathroom
For punk: Please Kill Me
For music and cultural history: The Rest Is Noise
For music, memory and the brain: This Is Your Brain on Music
Affiliate disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you make a qualifying purchase through one of them, Beats Unbound may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.
As an Amazon Associate Beats Unbound may earn from qualifying purchases.